Lucy Heartfilia glared at the couple in front of them in the Fairy Tail headquarters, tapping her feet against the floor as she did. Erza and Jellal were talking to each other again, with Erza braced over the bar counter while letting out one of her rare smiles. Her scarlet hair was swept over her shoulder, and she looked completely relaxed, though still wore her usual custom-made armor and blue skirt. Her black boots swayed as she bounced them, and her large breasts were braced on the counter as she sipped on her third drink.
Sitting next to her, Jellal was smiling as well. He didn’t visit Fairy Tail very frequently, mostly because of all that had happened throughout the years, but with him and Erza now in a steady relationship after he broke it off with his fiancee, he tried to visit as often as possible.
Lucy, like a lot of the rest of Natsu’s team and Fairy Tail members in general, still despised him for everything he’d done to them. She knew he had his reasons, but it still wasn’t good enough for her.
Jellal was wearing his usual attire, a dark white shirt with a blue tint under a hooded dark blue coat. His tattoo was a perfect match to Ezra’s hair, which he now played with his fingers, tugging on it as she beamed at him. The more Lucy watched, the more it pissed her off.
He didn’t belong here. Not at all. He was a foreigner to them, no matter how he’d known Ezra since she was a child. Lucy knew Ezra far better than he did now, and she was going to show him once and for all. She just needed to devise a proper plan.
Not being able to watch this scene unfold in front of her any longer, she left the headquarters, deciding to do a little shopping instead.
She was strolling along the streets when she spotted it, a potion store that she’d never seen before. It was hidden in the corner, like it was some sort of secret, and she was immediately enticed to find out more. The bell rang as she pushed it open, and an old lady sat in the back, surrounded by potions of all shapes and sizes.
“Hello, dearie,” the woman croaked, looking up at her from her knitting.
“Sorry, I should go,” Lucy said, and moved to leave the store at once.
“I have what you desire most, Lucy Heartfilia… if only you have the Jewels to purchase it,” she said mysteriously.
Lucy stopped in her tracks, and moved back, not being able to help herself from how fascinating the woman was. She stopped in front of her at the counter. “How do you know what I want?”
“I can see your deepest desires, it’s a skill of mine…” she answered. “You desire to claim Erza Scarlet’s love for your own.” Lucy gasped, she’d never spoken to anyone about this. Not out loud. The woman must’ve been somewhat honest if she was able to read her mind like this. “I have two potions that will help you accomplish your task,” she said, and reached downwards to pull two distinct bottles out, a pearlescent fluid in a long bottle and a blue slightly-transparent fluid in a circular short bottle.
“What am I supposed to do with them?” She asked. She would have the funds to pay this woman, since they’d just completed one of their jobs, and she was willing to do anything to get Erza’s heart at this point. No matter the consequences.
“Let me explain…” the woman began.
—--
Lucy stood in her apartment, only letting herself think through the entire plan for a second before she uncorked the blue potion and downed the whole thing. It tasted bitter, and her nerves were shot, worried that the woman had lied to her about this whole thing. Perhaps she had just willingly drank poison, and she would be dying at any second. Instead, she felt her body begin to quiver, every so slowly, until it centered on a single spot in her body. She pulled her pants down, revealing her thin laced white panties underneath, and saw everything happen at once.
Her clit began growing, larger, and larger, until it would no longer fit inside her panties without feeling painful. She pulled it down, and watched her new dick grow, larger and larger while still maintaining its flaccid form. Underneath it, she could feel herself getting heavier and heavier, as a set of balls emerged from underneath the futa, so large she didn’t think she didn’t think it was possible.
The witch had told her that it would be permanent, and to exercise caution before she decided to drink it, but now, looking down at her newly formed member, she’d never been so sure of something in her whole life. Her cock twitched, and she began stroking it, watching as it began swelling slowly until it was fully hard underneath her touch. It was pulsing, like it was ready to fuck, and beaded slightly at the tip. She stroked the veins on it, feeling the warmth, and felt powerful and strong, and she wondered if it was a side effect of the potion, or if she was finally what she was always supposed to be.
It didn’t matter now, because the witch had been honest, and Lucy was so ready for the next step of her plan.
—--
She sat next to Natsu, giving the fakest smile she possibly could to the couple sitting across from her. She had convinced Natsu to have a double date with her and Erza and Jellal, and he only agreed to it because she promised to pay for all the food he was surely going to consume. She poured some wine for the couple in front of her, and continued the conversation like nothing was wrong.
Halfway through the meal, she walked off to the waitstaff, and slipped them a huge wad of Jewels as well as the second potion. She winked them before heading back to her seat.
“Should we go to my apartment after this?” She asked. “I wouldn’t want the date to end so suddenly.”
“Wow, you never invite us to your place!” Natsu exclaimed.
“Yeah, because you always come in without bothering to ask me.” She rolled her eyes.
Jellal and Erza looked at each other, and Erza nodded. “Sure, we can come over.”
Natsu grinned as well, shoving another piece of meat in his mouth before he said with a muffled voice, “yeah, why not?! I’m always at your house anyways.”
Lucy, immensely pleased at how well her plan was working, shoved another spoonful of soup into her mouth.
An hour later, the four of them opened the door to her apartment. She’d known Natsu would agree to come, but that he would be asleep before long, since he’d completely overstuffed his belly like always. She spoke to Erza and Jellal about their latest mission while staring at the affectionate couple, who held hands and touched each other as often as they could. It made her want to puke, but she knew she would be getting her revenge before long.
When Natsu had finally fallen asleep at 9pm, the sound of his snoring echoing through the apartment, Lucy stood up, walking across the space to keep a distance from the couple, just in case the magic of the potion failed.
“There was a reason why I invited the two of you out on a date,” Lucy began, rubbing her fingers together like an evil mastermind. Erza and Jellal turned to her, both looking confused. “Did you think I forgave Jellal that easily, after everything he’d done to us. Everything he’d done to you?” She glared at Erza, disgust clear on her face. “And besides, I know you have problems in your relationship. I hear Erza complain to Mirajane about it all the time. You’re not good enough for her.” She seethed, her face turning more and more into her true self, her mask falling off piece by piece.
Erza’s face remained surprised as she said, “what are you going on about, Lucy?”
“I’m finally telling you how I really feel,” Lucy said. “How much disgust I feel about your stupid relationship.” She fished through the keys by her waist, and lifted her hands, “Open, gate of golden bull - Taurus!”
Her magic swelled around her, and Taurus appeared in front of them, his heavily muscular and athletic humanoid form facing his two friends turned enemies. “You called, my beautiful goddess?” He said, turning to face Lucy.
“Attack,” she said, her finger now directly pointed at Jellal and Erza.
Yes, this normally would’ve been a death wish. Lucy’s level of strength with her keys was nowhere close to the amount of power Erza and Jellal had combined. That was where the potion came into play. She was desperate for it to work, and had put all of her trust on the witch, who she had paid handsomely for her service.
Erza and Jellal stood up at once into a fighting position, though both looked hesitant to fight against their ally. “What the hell are you doing, Lucy? What’s gotten into you?” Erza asked in a desperate and hateful voice. She began trying to summon her weapon, and tried to change her body tight red dress back into her usual armor, but as she braced her body, nothing happened. She looked down at herself in surprise, then back at Lucy, like she would be able to explain what was happening.
Next to Erza, Jellal was going through the same thing. He tried to summon his Heavenly Body Magic, his fingers curling into fists, but the usual hum of strength he felt deep in his core was nowhere to be found, like someone had sapped it away from him, or locked it in some unknown depth.
Lucy smirked at them and tsked, “I’m shocked that two warriors like you hadn’t realized that your magic had been taken away from you. It was way too easy for me to do so.”
“I’ll ask you again,” Erza said, anger deep in her eyes. “What the fuck did you do to us?”
“Why do you think I invited you to dinner, huh?” Lucy said. “I needed a way to access the food you were eating.” She pulled the empty potion vial out of her pocket. “Though I could’ve never imagined something so powerful to be able to rid of your powers like this. I should go find the witch again and thank her,” she purred.
“I’ll never forgive you for this,” Erza said. “Though I believe someone must be controlling you. The real Lucy would never do something like this.”
“Oh?” Lucy replied. “But do you really know the real me?” She walked towards them now, feeling safer now that she was sure the second potion had worked. “Because the real me has always been in love with you Erza.” She finally admitted.
Erza turned to Jellal in shock, then back to Lucy. “You’re lying.”
“I’m not. And seeing your sickening relationship with Jellal, knowing you complain about him to Mirajane all the time. It’s ridiculous to me, and absolutely disgusting. You should be with me, and everyone knows it. We’re perfect for each other, and I’ll show you this very night,” it was a breath of relief, letting go of something that had been deep in her heart for many years.
“You may have gotten rid of our magic, but we still have our strength,” Jellal said. He put himself into fighting position again, ready to strike, but with one nod towards Taurus, he pounced, his body pushing against Jellals and holding him down onto the floor. Erza tried to fight him as she jumped upwards, but with her tight dress and lack of weapons, there was nothing much she could do other than stumble as she tried to approach.
“Actually, the potion didn’t just get rid of your magic. It sapped your strength, too.” Lucy smirked. “Honestly, with how well it’s working, I should’ve paid more for the witch’s services.” She glanced at Natsu once before saying, “let’s not disturb poor Natsu. Come, Taurus, bring them to the bedroom.”
“Yes, ma’am!” Taurus replied, excited for him to be part of his amazing show. He knew he wouldn’t be allowed to take part in it, as it’s Lucy’s show, but he would be able to watch, and that was enough for him.
He lifted the struggling Erza, picking her up and taking her to the bedroom, with Jellal glaring at Lucy as he did so. “You still have time to run,” Lucy winked at him from the kitchen by the doorway.
“I’m not leaving Erza, bitch,” he said, ferocity still in his voice. She would be breaking that spirit soon, she knew it. Normally, it would be impossible for Taurus to even go against Titania, but the potion had drained most of her strength, making it akin to a normal human’s, and there was nothing she was able to do against the giant bull. Lucy followed behind, knowing Jellal wasn’t going to try to escape, and grinned maliciously as Erza was dropped into her large bed, with Jellal following closely behind.
“What are you going to do to us?” Erza asked, turning so she was facing Lucy, her eyes shooting between Jellal and her, like she was planning on how to escape the situation.
“I’m going to fuck you in front of your precious boyfriend, of course, and then break both of you. I want you to admit that you’re mine, and no one else’s.” She said, and nodded at Taurus, who closed the bedroom door and stood at it to stand guard. She had already discussed all of this with him previously. “Now take off your clothes.” She said coldly to Erza.
“No,” Erza said in response, the wrath of Titania still strong.
“I’m not going to ask you again, Erza. There’s nothing you can do against me right now. Do it, and I’ll try not to harm your boyfriend too much.” She threatened.
Erza looked at Jellal, and leaned down to begin pulling her heels off. Jellal moved forwards, trying to stop her. “Don’t do it for me, Erza. I’m not worth it,” his voice had softened, like he was trying to protect her, which made Lucy even more angry with them.
“Shut up, loser,” she said to Jellal. He obeyed, having nothing else he could do. Erza ignored his pleas, and threw her heels to the side before reaching down on her red dress, a skin tight outfit with a slit cut up her legs. Lucy had wanted to lick the skin revealed by the slit all night. She began pulling the dress off of her body and over her head, revealing a matching set of panties and bra underneath, a sexy combination that was so unlike Erza’s usual clothing. Lucy felt a pang of anger and jealousy. “Were you going to wear this for Jellal tonight? For him to fuck you?” Erza only nodded in response. “Good,” Lucy concluded. “This will make it even funner for me, then. Now take the rest of it off.” She could’ve done it herself, but it was so much more satisfying to watch Erza do this with her own hands.
Erza continued to glare at her, and began unhooking her bra, letting her massive chests bounce in the air as she slipped it off. Lucy had seen her breasts before, since they frequented the bathhouses very often with each other, but seeing it in this context, knowing that she would be fucking her in just a few minutes, made her newly formed cock throb beneath her long aqua dress. “Stop… don’t do this…” Jellal couldn’t help but burst out. Lucy glared at him, and proceeded to slap him across his cheek. He held onto his cheek, his expression a portrait of shock.
“Don’t speak until spoken to, bitch,” she said, her voice more commanding than anyone had ever heard her before. It was almost like she was a different person.
Erza, now looking frightful for the first time in her life, pulled her panties off, revealing a scarlet well-groomed bush underneath. Lucy licked her lips in satisfaction. Yes, it was time for her to finally enjoy her prize.
“Stand there and watch,” she commanded Jellal, who could only stand in place, unable to do anything except look at his girlfriend with fear on his face. Taurus was right next to him, his cock grown so large it was visible underneath the thin fabric he always wore. Taurus was always a big fan of shows like this.
Lucy pushed Ezra down onto the bed, and pushed her mouth against hers. Erza refused to kiss her back, but Lucy didn’t care. She knew Erza would break soon. She slipped her tongue inside aggressively, pushing Erza’s lips apart as she did. She groaned, feeling the satisfaction she’d been craving for years now. She’d always desired Erza, and she was finally going to have her, and it was so much more delicious with Jellal standing there, watching, unable to do anything.
She reached her fingers down and began playing with Erza’s nipples, twisting them roughly between her fingers. Titania was able to take a lot of pain, and didn’t make a single noise and Lucy played with her roughly. Erza's skin was so soft, so delicate, it was shocking knowing how much she trained every single day. Lucy couldn’t wait to slide her cock between her giant breasts. She separated from her lips, looking down at the saliva between them, and began licking and sucking down her neck until she reached Erza’s nipples. She wrapped her mouth around them and sucked deeply, flicking her tongue over and over it as she did.
“Master, Jellal has closed his eyes. He’s not looking,” Taurus informed her.
Lucy reluctantly let go of Erza’s nipple, and glared up at Jellal. “Would you like another slap across the face? Next time Taurus informs me you’re not paying full attention to the show, I’ll show you what power I truly have.” She warned. Jellal opened his eyes at once, and Lucy continued to play with Erza. She pinched her nipple with one hand and sucked on Erza’s other nipple with her mouth. Erza was still trying her hardest not to make a single noise. Lucy glanced up at her, and saw Titania’s mouth was firmly shut.
She moved down lower and lower, kissing and sucking all of Erza’s soft skin until she eventually reached the spot between her legs. She inhaled deeply, soaking in the scent of her sex, a smell she’d imagined in her head many, many times. It was floral and musky, exactly what she’d imagined. She pushed her head into the scarlet pubic hair, nuzzling it before sticking her tongue out and pressing it against Erza’s clit. She gave it a long, tantalizing lick, then looked up to say, “I’m going to make you cum more times tonight than Jellal had ever given you in the entirety of your relationship.” Before either of them could reply, she began licking Erza’s clit again, determined to make Erza react for her. She was attentive to all of her movements, and moved her tongue to make her feel the most amount of pleasure. Soon, she could feel Erza get wetter and wetter underneath her expert mouth, and she stuck her fingers inside, feeling the tightness and her engorged pussy. “Fuck, you’re not making a single noise, but I can feel how wet you are for me.” She pulled her fingers out to show Jellal, who looked away in distaste.
“You must’ve drugged her,” he said at once.
Lucy winked at him. “Nah, she’s just turned on because I’m better than you.” She pushed her fingers inside of Erza again, her middle and index finger, and curled them so she was hitting Erza’s G-spot. She began licking her clit again as she pushed her fingers into her over and over, and was delighted when Erza let out a very quiet moan, unable to help herself. Lucy had never felt so proud of herself. She knew she was a better lover than Jellal, and now she had finally proven it to herself and her audience. “I see you’re finally letting yourself enjoy what I’m doing to you,” she teased in between licks. Erza ignored her, refusing to recognize that her body was starting to react.
Lucy increased her actions, faster and faster, until Erza was shaking underneath her, trying to maintain her composure but feeling intense lust at the same time. “Are you going to cum for me, in front of Jellal?” Lucy purred.
“Never,” Erza growled, but was starting to sound less and less convincing.
Lucy built her tempo, higher and higher, until it was too much for her to take. Her thighs quivered, threatening to lose control like the rest of her body, and Erza felt herself climb over the edge until she let out a loud gasp, her body trembling from head to toe from her orgasm. Her pussy pulsed over and over around Lucy’s fingers, making her think about how delicious it would be when she finally slid inside of her. “Yes… yes… cum for me…” she said, feeling absolutely elated. When Erza finally calmed down, she pulled back from her, her face and fingers now covered in her juices. Jellal stared at her with absolute hatred in his eyes, which made her even more joyous.
“Look what I did, Jellal, within just a few minutes. Look how I made Erza cum…” she goaded. She walked towards him and pushed him to the ground so he was forced onto his knees. She pushed her soaked fingers against his lips, and forced them open for her. He had no choice but to suck on them, tasting his girlfriend’s juices on Lucy’s hand as she fucked his mouth with them. When it was completely sucked clean, she pulled out, and realized what she had to do next. She was waiting for this precise moment.
“Would you like to do the honors?” She asked Taurus. Taurus smirked and approached, his erection obvious as he tugged on the zipper on the back of Lucy’s dress, lower and lower, until it slipped from her shoulders on both sides. The dress fell onto the floor, and Jellal gasped, unable to help himself. Standing right in front of his face was the largest cock he’d ever seen. And it belonged to Lucy, bobbing and beading at the tip. She held onto his chin and aggressively forced him to look up at her. “What do you think, huh? I’m going to fuck your girlfriend so hard with this cock her pussy will take the shape of it… she’ll never feel satisfied by you again.” She stroked herself confidently, then moved one more step so her cock was right in Jellal’s face. She pushed her way inside his mouth, forcing his mouth open to the extreme as she thrust her body into him. He gagged immediately, trying to hold onto anything around him to brace himself. Erza, finally bounced back from her first orgasm, let out a noise filled with shock as Lucy pushed her fingers into his blue hair and forced her way as deep as possible down his throat.
This was the first time anyone’s ever touched her newly formed cock other than her, and it felt absolutely amazing. She knew now why she’d always wanted a cock. It felt powerful, and like she could destroy anyone she’d ever laid her eyes on. All she had to do was to give them the same potion.
Tears began streaming down his eyes, but she didn’t care. In fact, she wanted to make him suffer as much as possible. He was barely about to breath in the onslaught, and saliva dripped down from his mouth onto her plush carpet. She could feel herself curve down his throat, feel the tightness at the back of his, her cock pulsing greedily with each thrust. Taurus watched every second of it from the door, looking like it was the best show he’d ever seen.
Lucy knew she’d be coming many many times that night, and let herself go over the edge as she let out a low strangled moan. Her cock became impossibly large as her balls tightened, and she came at once, with ropes and ropes of cum drenching his throat, forcing him to swallow every drop shameful as she exploded inside of him. It was so satisfying to see the pain in his eyes.
She pulled out of him, and realized it wasn’t enough. She had to make him feel even more shame. “Well, since you’ve already tasted some of my fluids,” she winked, and forced his mouth open again as she began urinating in his mouth. She aimed badly on purpose, drenching his face and evening attire with the yellow stream until she felt her bladder empty.
Erza, not being able to take it any longer, stood up to get to him, but Lucy turned at once, smiling at her with wicked amusement. “And where are you going, Erza Scarlet?” She mused
Erza stopped at once, knowing there was nothing she could do with her power so weak. “I gave you a second to rest, but now, now it’s your turn again,” Lucy said, and swayed her hips as she approached her, her cock now bobbing again from seeing Erza’s naked body, her pussy covered in a sheen of wetness from her orgasm. She flipped Erza around so she was on her knees and hand on the bed, and climbed onto the bed herself. “Prepare to forget about your stupid boyfriend’s cock,” Lucy said, and aligned her cock against Erza’s pussy before she pushed inside. She had done so with a large amount of force, but Erza's pussy was too tight for her large cock, and she only managed to push her dick in halfway. Erza gasped loudly, her pussy expanding to take on such a foreign object. It contracted around Lucy’s cock, getting used to its size, but Lucy did not have any patience, and pushed in again, as deep as she could get it. It hit all the way home this time, hitting right on Erza’s cervix, and she wrapped Erza’s hair around her fist as she began thrusting as fast as she could, not wanting to let Erza adjust to her size even for a second. Erza let out a loud cry, then began moaning over and over, her sensitive pussy completely being spread apart by Lucy’s size.
“How does it feel, huh? To have a cock inside of you that can actually satisfy you for the first time?” She had heard Erza’s complaints to Mirajane, how Jellal was always too busy to satisfy her, and knew how much Erza wanted to be truly destroyed. She pulled on her long silky hair as she moved inside of her over and over, and glanced over at Jellal, who was on his knees by the bed, looking completely broken and covered in her urine. Good, he had broken faster than she had imagined.
She angled her cock to aim down at Erza’s G-spot, and she slapped Erza hard against her ass, making it bounce against her body in satisfaction. Erza cried out, a mixture of pain and pleasure, and Lucy did the same to her other cheek. “You’re going to be craving this before long…” she purred, and moved her hand around to play with Erza’s clit. She was a woman, she knew exactly how to satisfy another woman, and she knew by the tightening of Erza’s cunt around her cock, she was close to cumming again. “Cum for me, Erza Scarlet, let me know what a whore you really are.” She increased her speed, and felt the moment Erza lost control of her body. It slumped over slightly as she came, her muscles spasming as she let out a loud moan. Her pussy clenching over and over around Lucy’s cock was too much for her to take, and she let herself cum as well, jet after jet of sticky warm cum pouring into Erza’s pussy, as deep inside of her as it could possibly go. Erza could feel it drench her insides, and her pussy craved it, like it wanted to be impregnated, like this was what was meant to happen. She cursed her body for being so weak. It was all Jellal’s fault. He never let her cum without satisfying himself first.
Lucy pulled out of her and gave Erza’s ass another hard spank, and left Titania to fall back onto the bed. She ordered Taurus to lift Jellal up and place him on the bed next to Titania, his ass in the air like hers was. Lucy pressed her half-erect dick against his ass, and began stroking herself on it, using his asscheeks to grind over and over. She saw Jellal look over at his lover, his expression full of torment as he watched her on the bed. Erza looked back at him with the same expression, neither of them knowing what to do.
Lucy, now erect for the third time, probably due to the tremendous magic of the old lady, pushed her cock against Jellal’s asshole. Her newly formed cock had felt a mouth and pussy for the first time today, why not enjoy an ass pussy for the first time as well? Her large head pushed into Jellal’s ass, pushing it apart, and he let out a cry of intense pain. She had purposefully not lubricated him, with the only small bit of lubrication being Erza’s soaked pussy juice still on his cock. She didn’t warm him up, and pushed against the tight hole, expanding it little by little as she tore him apart.
He tried his hardest to pull away from her, but she held him steady, her strength, normally weak, was easily overpowering him at this point. He was in so much pain he gripped onto the comforter underneath him, trying to maintain any sense of control, but it was no use. The pain was just too much.
Lucy began fucking him just as she did with Erza, but barely caring whether or not he was enjoying himself. This was for pain, not for pleasure. She wanted to truly punish him. “Do you like my cock, stupid little Jellal? How does it feel deep inside of you, making you a little slut for me?” He ignored her, his face buried deep in the blankets. She moved her hand around and cupped his balls, pretending like she was going to stroke and play with them at first, but then started squeezing tight, her hands grasping harder and harder. She pushed her long fingernails inside of him, making him cry out in pain. She squeezed as hard as she possibly could, still stroking inside of him over and over as she did. He tried so hard to push away, and Taurus appeared next to her, holding him down. “Good boy,” she said. She would have to call him up again next to time she fucked Jellal and Erza, since he was enjoying himself so much.
“Please, please stop,” Erza said, tears forming in her eyes. It was shocking to see the Erza Scarlet break apart like this. It usually took a lot to ruin her, and Lucy had finally gotten to that point.
“I don’t know, I think he’s enjoying himself,” Lucy replied, and continued playing with his balls as hard as she could, leaving red marks from where her nails pinched him. She scratched down his back as well, leaving a trail of red marks along its wake. She commanded Erza to sit up, and pressed her lips against hers roughly, her tongue pushing its way in as she kissed her while fucking her boyfriend. She could taste Erza’s salty tears in her mouth, making it all so delicious.
It didn’t take long for Lucy to cum again. Watching Jellal struggle made it so easy for her to swell up again, but instead of cummming inside of his ass, she pulled out of him and pushed back into Erza’s cunt. “I want to make sure I breed you, you little slut,” she said. She pinched Erza’s nipples as she came, adding onto the load that was already starting to seep out of Erza’s pussy. “You keep that all in, or I’m going to make Jellal eat my cum off of you.” She said coldly as she pulled out.
For the rest of the night, she continued to rape them over and over again, making sure she unloaded into Erza’s pussy each time. She lost count of how many times Erza had cum, but she hadn’t let Jellal cum even once. Not even close.
It was by far the greatest night of her life, and by the end of it, she knew she had truly and utterly broken them.
—-- 5 months later —---
Jellal knelt by her bed, completely naked, with a leash around his neck, the other end attached to the bed. Lucy was fucking a pregnant Erza, a belly so round it looked like it was about to burst, bouncing her over and over on the bed with her tits right in front of Jellal’s face, so he could see every second of his girlfriend’s torture. Though really, they were no longer girlfriend and boyfriend, not after what Lucy had done to them day after day.
They never told anyone else in the guild what Lucy had done to them, both being too embarrassed to say anything, and so far, everyone had assumed the baby was Jellal’s. How wrong they were.
Every night, Jellal and Erza were forced to come home with Lucy, and she fucked and played with them however she wished, torturing and pleasuring them each and every night until their minds went insane.
She was so excited for Erza to give birth to their sweet child, and for her to impregnate her once more. The witch had truly become the best thing that’s ever happened to her.